When examiners and teachers mark your work, they look for both
'routine' and 'subtle' levels of analysis. Clearly the more 'subtle' areas you
hit, the higher your mark!
Analysing any text at the level of ideology is capable of
easily producing a very subtle analysis of the kind that gains the highest
marks. You'll be able to apply the techniques covered here to texts you are
studying for English
Literature, English Language or Media Studies.
What is Ideology?
An
ideology is a type of idea. It's not the personal ideas we might
have such as, 'I
have an idea what Laura would like for her birthday'; for an idea to be labelled
as an ideology, it needs to be one of the many widely held and shared ideas we
each have such as, 'I have a right to choose what I do with my
life' or 'All people have a right to be treated equally' and so on.
Together, these many shared ideas - ideologies - create what we could call our 'system of beliefs', which some call our 'world view'
or 'mind set'.
It is the ideologies we all share,
sometimes referred to as 'dominant' or
'prevailing'
ideologies, that mould and shape our ways of thinking about
society, the world and its peoples.
- There are many reasons why ideologies are
worthy of close study but two stand out as important:
a) we hold to them usually unquestioningly
even though
they are not our own ideas, i.e. the ideas originated
in someone else's
mind.
b) we hold to them so closely that we tend to see them as too obvious
to question, as common sense or as natural.
- How can it be it that a particular set of
someone else's ideas manages to catch hold and exert such a grip, or spread so
quickly and widely throughout virtually a whole culture or society?
- And when we do accept someone
else's ideas about how we ought to think and
live our own lives, shouldn't we ask whose ideas they are, what
possible motives lie
behind them and
who is likely to most benefit from the rest of us holding them?
- Some types of ideology have a religious origin;
these often form our society's moral values.
- Many ideologies seem to have
a political origin arising from government and its laws.
- The media play a part
in maintaining and reinforcing certain important ideologies.
- Literature is thought to be unique
in the way it can expose
ideologies.
- It can be shown that texts of all kinds - literary texts
such as novels, plays and poems, most
non-fiction writing and all media texts - can be convincingly argued to work at an
ideological level. This simply means that they work in various ways -
and always transparently (i.e. not obviously) - to support and
reinforce a particular way of thinking about and viewing the world.
- It is convincingly argued by political thinkers called
Marxists that Western dominant ideologies act to support
a particular kind of social structure or society, one that is hierarchical
and, thus, competitive, rather than one that is co-operative and egalitarian.
Two important modern theorists worthy of further study at A-level are
Louis Althusser and
Theodor Adorno.
- If you think, to take just a
few examples, of how women were once viewed in relation
to men... of how the educated are viewed in relation to the uneducated...
of how the rich are considered in relation to the poor... of the old compared to the young, and so on...
these are all key dominant ideologies. Each of these could be viewed as
not only ways of thinking but of a system of thinking that could be argued
to act in ways that
keep our culture as a highly competitive rather than a highly co-operative
place in which to live out our lives... and competition could be argued to tend to favour
the few rather than the many - the rich rather than the poor, for example?
- Some would argue that all language
is ideological (i.e. it supports a particular way of thinking...) and few
would disagree that many everyday words are, at least, ideologically
loaded.
- When a woman chooses to end her pregnancy,
for example, the action she undertakes
might be termed 'abortion', 'getting rid of it', 'termination'... Can you
see how each of these terms are ideologically loaded - that is, they
each carry with them a kind of ideological baggage that creates,
reinforces or suggests a particular mind set?
- Another example is the
current term used for a woman who is going to have a baby, 'pregnant'. Not
so long ago the term used was 'expecting', and before that, 'with child'.
The current term might be argued to be ideologically loaded because it is
taken from a clinical semantic field
- a similar field, in fact, to the word 'abortion'. The ideological
implications of this change of usage could be argued to support a particular
way of thinking - in this case that abortion is an acceptable choice. If you
link the current term 'termination' with the older term 'with child' you
should be able to recognise that that combination acts to
foreground a rather less easily acceptable way of thinking or
ideological standpoint.
- It is interesting to consider
how and why such older terms fall out of usage. Just when did we stop saying
'expecting a child' or 'she is with child' - and why? Were politicians
or the media involved in this change? And if so, how and
why was this done? Was it merely fashion or is it to reinforce
a particular way of thinking that supports a political view? It is this
kind of questioning that makes studying ideology important and fascinating.
- Ideologies pervade our minds at every turn;
they guide our thoughts; they determine our actions - in ways that can be
surprising, sometimes shocking, and occasionally tragic.
